Tourism Efficiency: Bootstrap-Data Envelopment and Tobit Panel Data Analysis


  • Güven GÜNEY



Bootstrap, Data envelopment analysis, Efficiency, Tobit panel data analysis, Tourism


Tourism is an important sector for countries, not only for cultural but also for economic activities. The tourism sector, which operates effectively, contributes to the development of the country's economy. Therefore, the study aims at calculating tourism efficiency and identifying factors that influence it. The study discussed 18 European countries that are among the world's major destination centers. Firstly, tourism efficiency scores were calculated with the data covering the period 2002-2019. Inputs are the number of tourists and tourism expenditures, and output is tourism revenues. Tourism sector efficiency was calculated with the standard Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) model. Because of the possible statistical limitations of the DEA method, analysis was repeated with the Bootstrap-DEA method. The resulting efficiency scores were used as dependent variables in the Tobit model. The variables including per capita income, digitalization, energy consumption, financial development, political stability, and life expectancy at birth were handled as new trends of tourism efficiency in the Tobit panel data analysis. Boostrap DEA results, which yield more accurate results, gave efficiency results for a smaller number of countries than the efficiency analysis performed with standard DEA. Tobit panel data analysis results showed that income per capita, digitalization, political stability, and life expectancy at birth enhanced tourism efficiency. In the study, unlike the literature, tourism efficiency was not considered at the level of companies, but at the level of countries. In addition to the standard DEA analysis, the Bootstrap DEA method was used, which yielded superior results. Additionally, not only the efficiency values were calculated in the study, but also the factors affecting the tourism efficiency were determined.


Banker, R. D., Charnes, A. & Cooper, W. W. (1984), Some models for estimating technical and scale inefficiencies in data envelopment analysis, Management Science, Vol.30, No.9, pp.1078-1092.

Barišić, P. & Cvetkoska, V. (2020) Analyzing the efficiency of travel and tourism in the European Union, In Advances in operational research in the Balkans (pp. 167-186). Springer, Cham.

Bayrak, R. & Bahar, O. (2018), Economic efficiency analysis of tourism sector in OECD countries: An emprical study with DEA, Internatonal Journal of Administrative Studies, Vol.20, pp. 83-100.

Beck, T., Feyen, E., Ize, A. & Moizeszowicz, F. (2008), Benchmarking financial development, Working paper, World Bank Financial and Private Sector Development Vice Presidency Financial Policy Development Unit, June.

Bronzini, R., Ciani, E. & Montaruli, F. (2022). Tourism and local growth in Italy, Regional Studies, Vol.56 No.1, pp.140-154.

Buhalis, D. (2000), Marketing the competitive destination of the future, Tourism Management, Vol.21 No.1, pp. 97-116.

Churchill, S. A., Cai, Y., Erdiaw-Kwasie, M. O. & Pan, L. (2022), Financial development and tourism: A century of evidence from Germany, Applied Economics,

Cunha, L. (2014), The definition and scope of tourism: A necessary inquiry, Cogitur, Journal of Tourism Studies, n.5, pp. 91-114.

Ding, G. & Wu, J. (2022), Influence of tourism safety perception on destination image: A case study of Xinjiang, China, Sustainability, Vol.14, No.3 1663, 1-21.

Efron, B. (1979), Computers and the theory of statistics: Thinking the unthinkable, SIAM Review, Vol. 21 No.4, pp.460-480.

Efron, B. & Tibshrani, R. J. (1994), An introduction to the Bootstrap, CRC Press.

Ferrier, G. D. & Hirschberg, J. G. (1997), Bootstrapping confidence intervals for linear programming efficiency scores: With an illustration using Italian banking data, Journal of Productivity Analysis, Vol.8, No.1, pp.19-33.

Firoiu, D. & Croitoru, A. (2013), Tourism and tourism infrastructure from the perspective of technological changes, Romanian Economic and Business Review, Vol. 8, No. 2, pp. 93-103.

Frantál, B. & Urbánková, R. (2017). Energy tourism: An emerging field of study, Current Issues in Tourism, Vol.20, No.13, pp.1395-1412.

Gao, J., Shao, C. & Chen, S. (2022), Evolution and driving factors of the spatiotemporal pattern of tourism efficiency at the provincial level in china based on SBM–DEA model, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol.19, No.16, 10118.

Gray, M. (1997), The political economy of tourism in Syria: State, society, and economic liberalization, Arab Studies Quarterly, Vol. 19, No.2, pp. 57-73.

Hadad, S., Hadad, Y., Malul, M. & Rosenboim, M. (2012), The economic efficiency of the tourism industry: A global comparison, Tourism Economics, Vol.18, No.5, pp. 931-940.

Heung, V. C. S., Qu, H. & Chu R. (2001), The relationship between vacation factors and socio-demographic and traveling characteristics: The case of Japanese leisure travellers, Tourism Management, Vol. 22, No.3, pp. 259-269.

Hollingsworth, B. (2003), Non-parametric and parametric applications measuring efficiency in health care, Health Care Management Science, Vol.6 No.4, pp.203-218.

Hosseini, S. P. & Hosseini, S. M. (2021), Efficiency assessment of tourism industry in developing countries in the context of infrastructure: A two-stage super-efficiency slacks-based measure, Open Journal of Social Sciences, Vol.9 No.04, 346-372.

IEA (2002), Data and statistics, (accessed 20 February 2022).

IMF (2022), Financial development index database, (accessed 20 February 2022).

Khan, M. T. I., Yaseen, M. R. & Ali, Q. (2019), Nexus between financial development, tourism, renewable energy, and greenhouse gas emission in high-income countries: A continent-wise analysis, Energy Economics, Vol.83, pp.293-310.

Khanal, A., Rahman, M.M., Khanam, R. & Velayutham, E. (2021), Are tourism and energy consumption linked? Evidence from Australia, Sustainability, Vol.13, No.19 10800, pp. 1-20.

Mushtaq, A. & Zaman, K. (2014), The relationship between political instability, terrorism and tourism in Saarc Region, Journal of Economic Info, Vol.1, No.1, pp.23-40.

Pavković, V., Jević, G., Jević, J., Nguyen, P. T. & Sava, C. (2021), Determining efficiency of tourism sector in certain European countries and regions by applying DEA analysis, Journal of Process Management and New Technologies, Vol.9 No.3-4, pp.49-61.

Pegkas, P. (2022), The efficiency of the tourism industry in Greece during the economic crisis (2008-2016), European Journal of Tourism Research, Vol.32, pp.3207-3207.

Ramanathan, R., (2003), An introduction to data envelopment analysis: A tool for performance measurement, Sage Publications, New Delhi.

Rasoulzadeh, M., Astaneh, H. K., Zareei, A. & Rahnama, A. (2017), The efficiency of tourism industry based on data envelopment analysis between the Middle East and East Asian Countries, International Journal of Applied Business and Economic Research, Vol.15, No.5, pp.141-153.

Simar, L. & Wilson, P. (1998), Sensitivity analysis of efficiency scores: how to bootstrap in nonparametric frontier models, Management Science, Vol.44, No.1, pp.49-61.

Simar, L. & Wilson, P. (1999), Estimating and bootstrapping Malmquist indices, European Journal of Operational Research, Vol.115 No.3, pp.459-471.

Simar, L. & Wilson, P. (2000a), A general methodology for Bootstrapping in nonparametric frontier models, Journal of Applied Statistics, 27 (6), pp.779-802.

Simar, L. & Wilson, P. (2000b), Statistical inference in nonparametric frontier models: The state of the art, Journal of Productivity Analysis, Vol.13 No.1, pp.49-78.

Sherman, H. D., (1982), Data envelopment analysis as a new managerial audit methodology: Test and evaluation, Auditing: A Journal of Practice and Theory, Vol. 4, No.1.

Sirakaya, E. & MCLelland, R. W. (1997), Factors affecting vacation destination choices of college students. Anatolia: An International, Journal of Tourism and Hospitality Research, Vol.8, No.3, pp.31-44.

Smeekes, S. (2009), Bootstrapping nonstationary time series, Universitaire Pers Maastricht.

Soysal-Kurt, H. (2017), Measuring tourism efficiency of european countries by using data envelopment analysis, European Scientific Journal, Vol.13, No.10, pp.31-49.

Stipanuk, D. M. (1993), Tourism and technology, Tourism Management, Vol.14 No.4, pp. 267-278.

UNWTO (2014), UNWTO tourism highlights, 2014 edition, (accessed 20 March 2022).

UNWTO (2022), Glossary of tourism terms, (accessed 20 March 2022).

Wang, X. C. & Kim, H. H. (2021), Using DEA method to measure and evaluate tourism efficiency of Guangdong, Guangxi and Hainan provinces in the South of China-A case of the Beibu Gulf urban agglomeration, International Journal of Advanced Smart Convergence, Vol.10, No.1, pp.24-37.

Wenhua, L. (2021), Research on the tourism efficiency in Guangxi- Based on DEA-Malmquist model, In E3S Web of Conferences, Vol. 251, 01082.

WGI (2022), Worldwide govarnence indicators, (accessed 20 February 2022).

Williams, A. M. & Hall, C. M. (2000), Tourism and migration: New relationships between production and consumption, Tourism Geographies, Vol. No.1, pp.5-27.

World Bank (2022), World development indicators,, (accessed 20 February 2022).

Yang, G., Yang, Y., Gong, G. & Gui, Q. (2022), The spatial network structure of tourism efficiency and its influencing factors in China: A social network analysis, Sustainability, Vol.14, No.16, 9921.

Yi, T. & Liang, M. (2015), Evolutional model of tourism efficiency based on the DEA method: A case study of cities in Guangdong Province, China, Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research, Vol.20 No.7, pp.789-806.

Yun, Yeboon B., Nakayama, H. & Tanino, T., (2004), Continuous optimization a generalized model for data envelopment analysis, European Journal of Operational Research, Vol.157 No.1, pp.87-105.

Zaman, K., Shahbaz, M., Loganathan, N., & Raza, S. A. (2016), Tourism development, energy consumption and Environmental Kuznets Curve: Trivariate analysis in the panel of developed and developing countries, Tourism Management, Vol.54, pp. 275-283.

Zhang, R. (2020), Research on the relationship between residents’ income growth and tourism consumption: A case study of Wuhan, Modern Economy, Vol.11, pp. 763-775.

Zhang, Y. & Fu, Y. (2021), The measurement and promotion strategy of provincial tourism efficiency in china based on three-stage DEA and Malmquist Index, In 1st International Symposium on Innovative Management and Economics (ISIME 2021), Atlantis Press, pp. 387-402.



How to Cite

GÜNEY , G. ., TOPÇUOĞLU, Özlem, & BOZKURT , E. . (2023). Tourism Efficiency: Bootstrap-Data Envelopment and Tobit Panel Data Analysis . Journal of Tourism & Gastronomy Studies, 11(3), 2171–2186.